LI fire districts hold public budget hearings

BY LAURA ALBANESE | laura.albanese@newsday.com

October 17, 2007


Fire districts across the Island opened up their yearly budgets to public scrutiny for the first time last night to mixed results - with some districts attracting dozens of participants and others attracting none.

More than 40 people attended the hourlong public budget meeting in Gordon Heights, a district that boasts the highest fire tax on Long Island, said Gina Previte, a Medford resident who pays $2,519 annually.

In the past, Previte said, budget information wasn't always readily available. She said the public hearing was a small step in the right direction for a community that "can't afford to stay , but can't afford to leave."


"Everyone here is feeling very burdened," Previte said, and a number of them, like Rosalie Hanson, also of Medford, planned to use their allotted time to air out grievances.

In Massapequa and Wantagh, it was another story. There, the meetings, which consisted of detailed PowerPoint presentations on yearly expenditures, lasted 15 minutes with nearly no comments. Six people attended the meeting at Wantagh, whose district covers 11.5 square miles and has a budget of more than $6 million. No non-fire personnel attended the meeting in Massapequa.

Though the turnout was small, transparency was the ultimate goal, said Wantagh Fire Commissioner Craig Craft.

"We're out there protecting our residents, and certainly our residents are entitled to see how their money is being spent," he said.

Districts were required to publicize the hearings' date on all town and fire Web sites and on signs in front of town halls and firehouses, the result of a new state law that requires increased transparency on how districts spend their money.

The meetings, which were set to occur on the same night at all of Long Island's 867 districts [CORRECTION: There are 179 fire districts and departments on Long Island. The number was incorrect in a story yesterday. PG. A19 NS 10/18/07], will improve the districts' relationships with local communities, said William N. Young, counsel for the Association of Fire Districts of the State of New York, a group that supported the legislation to have the hearings.

"The public will see that what we do is in their best interests ... and that [the money] all goes back into the community," Young said.

Still, he conceded, there would be growing pains.

"This is definitely a work in progress," he said, adding that the idea took some getting used to for much of Long Island's mostly volunteer force.

"People were like, 'How come? We're volunteers. Why do we have to do this?'" Young said. But after a series of meetings explaining the changes, many had changed their minds, he said.

"While they're not universally embracing this transparency, the majority [are]," Young said. And as districts acclimate to the change, their abilities to "handle these types of hearings will only improve as we go along," he said.


October 17, 2007


The Board of Fire Commissioners

Gordon Heights Fire District

23 Hawkins Avenue

Medford, NY  11763

 

Dear Fire Commissioners:

 

I attended your budget hearing last night, and was very disappointed in how it was conducted.  As a hard working taxpayer, I expected to be able to ask questions and expected them to be answered as well.  Especially since we pay the highest fire taxes of any Brookhaven Fire District.  My friend lives in the Middle Island District and they allowed questions.  So, I must conclude that you chose not to follow this option.

 

I was also very disappointed that you did not allow one of the residents to tape this public meeting.  I am sure many homeowners who could not attend because they were working late or could not arrange a babysitter would have liked to view the meeting at a more convenient time.  You told this resident it was prevented because of homeland security policy.  I would personally like to see that policy in writing.

 

Finally, I heard many residents express they felt making "comments" rather then being able to ask questions was a waste of our time.  We believe you are well aware of how we feel about the high taxes, and yet there has been no effort to restructure your district operation to create any real tax relief.  The grants you informed us of receiving for new trucks are very much appreciated, but are just not effective in solving our real issue, which is the ongoing out of control tax rate.

 

Sincerely,

 

Greg Walsh